Complete Guide to Concrete Workability Classes, Slump Values, Compacting Factor, Vebe Time, Slump Flow & Consistency Tests — IS 456, IS 1199, ASTM C143, EN 206 & ACI 211.1
View Workability ChartsWorkability is the property of freshly mixed concrete that determines the ease and homogeneity with which it can be mixed, placed, consolidated, and finished. It is not a single measurable quantity but a composite of several interrelated properties including consistency (resistance to flow), mobility (ease of movement under applied force), stability (resistance to segregation and bleeding), and compactability (ease of achieving full consolidation). According to IS 456:2000 Clause 7 and ACI 211.1, workability must be specified and achieved for every concrete mix to ensure structural integrity and durability.
In 2026, workability specification has evolved significantly. The conventional slump test (ASTM C143 / IS 1199) remains the most widely used field test, but modern concrete types — particularly self-compacting concrete (SCC), ultra-high-performance concrete (UHPC), 3D-printable concrete, and roller-compacted concrete (RCC) — require different test methods that better capture their unique fresh-state behaviour. The EN 206:2013+A2:2021 consistency class system and EFNARC SCC test suite are increasingly adopted globally alongside traditional IS and ASTM slump criteria.
The most comprehensive cross-standard workability correlation chart available. Values show the relationship between workability description, slump range, compacting factor, Vebe time, and flow diameter for each workability class. Reference: IS 456:2000 Table 1, ASTM C143, and EN 206 Table 1.
← Scroll left/right to view full table
| Workability Class | Slump Range (mm) — IS 456 / ASTM C143 | EN 206 Slump Class | Compacting Factor (IS 1199) | Vebe Time (sec) | Flow Table Spread (mm) | Degree of Workability |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Very Low / Zero Slump | 0 – 25 mm | S1 (10–40 mm) | 0.70 – 0.80 | 20 – 35 sec | 250 – 340 mm | Very low — harsh, stiff mix |
| Low Workability | 25 – 75 mm | S1–S2 (10–90 mm) | 0.80 – 0.87 | 11 – 20 sec | 340 – 420 mm | Low — needs good vibration |
| Medium Workability | 75 – 125 mm | S2–S3 (50–150 mm) | 0.87 – 0.92 | 5 – 10 sec | 420 – 480 mm | Medium — standard vibration adequate |
| High Workability | 125 – 175 mm | S3–S4 (100–180 mm) | 0.92 – 0.95 | 3 – 6 sec | 480 – 560 mm | High — light tamping or minimal vibration |
| Very High Workability | 175 – 220 mm | S4–S5 (160–220 mm) | 0.95 – 0.97 | 0 – 3 sec | 560 – 620 mm | Very high — flowing under own weight |
| Flowing Concrete | ≥ 220 mm | S5 (≥ 220 mm) | 0.97 – 0.98 | 0 – 1 sec | ≥ 620 mm | Flowing — essentially self-levelling |
| SCC — Self-Compacting Concrete 2026 | Slump flow: 550–850 mm (not cone slump) | SF1: 550–650 mm SF2: 660–750 mm SF3: 760–850 mm |
0.98+ | N/A | ≥ 700 mm (J-ring flow) | Self-compacting — no vibration needed |
| RCC — Roller-Compacted Concrete 2026 | 0 mm (no slump) | No slump class — use Vebe | 0.70 – 0.78 | 30 – 120 sec (VeBe on vibrating table) | N/A | Dry/stiff — compacted by roller equipment |
| UHPC — Ultra-High Performance Concrete 2026 | Slump flow: 200–260 mm (mini-slump cone) | No standard class — use flow cone | 0.98+ | N/A | ≥ 700 mm (adapted flow table) | Highly fluid despite low w/c (<0.25) |
| 3D-Printable Concrete 2026 | Mini-slump: 50–90 mm (150mm cone) | No standard class yet | 0.75 – 0.85 | N/A | N/A — shape retention governs | Thixotropic — fluid when pumped, rigid at rest |
The European standard EN 206:2013+A2:2021 classifies fresh concrete consistency into multiple class systems depending on the test method used — slump classes (S), flow classes (F), Vebe classes (V), and compacting factor classes (C). The National Annexes of individual EU/UK countries specify which class system applies in each context.
← Scroll left/right to view full table
| EN 206 Slump Class | Slump Range (mm) | Workability Level | Equivalent IS 456 Class | Equivalent ASTM Range | Typical Application |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| S1 | 10 – 40 mm | Stiff / Low | Very Low | 0–50 mm (Low slump) | Lightly reinforced slabs, road pavements, precast (with vibration) |
| S2 | 50 – 90 mm | Medium-Low | Low–Medium | 50–100 mm | Standard reinforced concrete — beams, slabs, columns with normal vibration |
| S3 | 100 – 150 mm | Medium-High | Medium–High | 100–150 mm | General structural concrete, pumped concrete, walls with congested reinforcement |
| S4 | 160 – 210 mm | High | High | 150–200 mm | Highly congested reinforcement, diaphragm walls, deep pile construction, tremie concrete |
| S5 | ≥ 220 mm | Very High / Flowing | Very High | ≥ 200 mm | Flowing concrete, near-SCC, underwater tremie, heavily congested sections |
← Scroll left/right to view full table
| Vebe Class | Vebe Time (seconds) | Workability Description | Typical Application |
|---|---|---|---|
| V0 | ≥ 31 sec | Extremely Stiff | Roller-compacted concrete (RCC), dry lean concrete for pavements |
| V1 | 21 – 30 sec | Very Stiff | Precast concrete with heavy compaction, road base, dry-cast pipes |
| V2 | 11 – 20 sec | Stiff | Precast with standard vibration, concrete block manufacturing, heavy unreinforced sections |
| V3 | 6 – 10 sec | Medium | Mass concrete, large footings, lightly reinforced retaining walls |
| V4 | 3 – 5 sec | Medium-High | Standard reinforced concrete sections where slump test is impractical (<25mm slump) |
← Scroll left/right to view full table
| Flow Class | Flow Table Spread (mm) | Approx. Slump Equivalent (mm) | Typical Use |
|---|---|---|---|
| F1 | ≤ 340 mm | 0 – 25 mm | Stiff precast, dry concrete products |
| F2 | 350 – 410 mm | 25 – 50 mm | Low workability structural concrete |
| F3 | 420 – 480 mm | 50 – 100 mm | Normal structural concrete, standard vibration |
| F4 | 490 – 550 mm | 100 – 150 mm | Pumped concrete, congested reinforcement sections |
| F5 | 560 – 620 mm | 150 – 200 mm | High workability concrete, tremie, deep piles |
| F6 | ≥ 630 mm | ≥ 200 mm (approaching SCC) | Flowing concrete, near-SCC, complex formwork |
← Scroll left/right to view full table
| SCC Class | Slump Flow (mm) | T500 Target (sec) | Viscosity Class (VS/VF) | Typical Application |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| SF1 | 550 – 650 mm | ≥ 3 sec (VS2/VF2) | Moderate viscosity | Unreinforced or lightly reinforced members, simple formwork; low risk of segregation |
| SF2 | 660 – 750 mm | 2 – 5 sec (VS1 or VS2) | Medium viscosity | General structural SCC — walls, columns, deep beams; most common SCC class |
| SF3 | 760 – 850 mm | ≤ 3 sec (VS1/VF1) | Low viscosity, high fluidity | Very congested reinforcement, tall vertical elements, complex formwork; requires VMA for stability |
Correct workability selection is critical — too low causes inadequate compaction and honeycombing; too high risks segregation, bleeding, and reduced durability. The following table provides recommended slump ranges for all major concrete applications as per IS 456:2000 Table 2, ACI 211.1 Table 6.3.1, and current 2026 practice.
← Scroll left/right to view full table
| Type of Construction / Application | Recommended Slump — IS 456 (mm) | Recommended Slump — ACI 211.1 (mm) | EN 206 Slump Class | Workability Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Blinding / Lean Concrete, PCC | 25 – 75 | 25 – 75 | S1–S2 | Low workability acceptable — no reinforcement; hand compaction or roller |
| Mass Concrete — Dams, Raft Foundations | 25 – 50 | 25 – 75 | S1–S2 | Low slump preferred to reduce heat of hydration and shrinkage; internal vibrators used |
| Lightly Reinforced Sections — Slabs, Footings | 50 – 100 | 50 – 100 | S2 | Standard vibration adequate; maintain slump at lower end for economy |
| Heavily Reinforced Sections — Beams, Columns | 75 – 125 | 75 – 100 | S2–S3 | Adequate fluidity needed to pass through reinforcement without segregation |
| Walls — Normal Reinforcement Density | 75 – 125 | 75 – 125 | S2–S3 | Vibrator insertion spacing critical; concrete must flow around formwork ties |
| Pumped Concrete — Up to 30m Pump Height | 100 – 150 | 100 – 150 | S3 | Higher workability needed for pumpability; slump measured at discharge point (not drum) |
| Pumped Concrete — High-Rise (>80m) 2026 | 150 – 200 | 150 – 200 | S3–S4 | High slump + PCE superplasticizer essential; viscosity must be controlled to prevent blockage |
| Bridge Decks — Reinforced Concrete | 75 – 125 | 75 – 100 | S2–S3 | Balance workability with durability — avoid high slump that increases w/c and chloride permeability |
| Precast Concrete — Standardly Vibrated | 25 – 75 | 25 – 75 | S1–S2 | Controlled factory vibration allows lower slump; improves demoulding time and reduces shrinkage |
| Precast Concrete — Self-Consolidating (SCC) 2026 | Slump flow: 600–750 mm | Slump flow: 550–700 mm | SF1–SF2 | No vibration; superior surface finish; widely adopted in precast industry 2024–2026 |
| Underwater / Tremie Concrete | 150 – 200 | 150 – 225 | S4–S5 | High workability essential — concrete must flow under own weight through tremie pipe without segregation; use VMA |
| Shotcrete — Wet Process 2026 | 75 – 125 (before nozzle) | 75 – 125 | S2–S3 | Workable at pump; set accelerator added at nozzle causes immediate stiffening on surface |
| Roller-Compacted Concrete (RCC) — Pavements | 0 mm (Vebe: 30–120 sec) | 0 mm | V0–V1 | No slump — compacted by vibratory roller; consistency by Vebe test only |
| Concrete Pavements / Roads | 20 – 50 | 25 – 75 | S1 | Low workability for slip-form paving; maintains edge stability; surface texturing requires stiff mix |
| Floor Slabs — Industrial / Warehouse | 75 – 100 | 75 – 100 | S2 | Medium slump for laser screed finishability; avoid excess water — causes surface scaling and low abrasion resistance |
| UHPC — Reactive Powder Concrete 2026 | Slump flow: 200–260mm (mini-cone) | N/A (flow cone used) | No standard class | Highly fluid despite very low w/c (0.14–0.22) due to PCE superplasticizer; no coarse aggregate |
| Micro-Concrete / Repair Mortar | Flow: 100–150% (flow table) | Flow test used | F4–F6 | High fluidity needed for placement in thin, congested sections; tested by flow table not slump cone |
| Grouting / Void Filling | Flowable — no slump test | Flow cone test (ASTM C939) | No slump class | Self-levelling grout; flow time 11–30 sec (ASTM C939 flow cone); w/c controlled carefully |
Different workability tests suit different concrete types and workability ranges. Selecting the correct test is as important as the target value. Reference: IS 1199 (Parts 1–6, 2018) and BS EN 12350 (Parts 1–12).
← Scroll left/right to view full table
| Test Method | Standard Reference | Applicable Slump Range | Equipment Required | Test Duration | Best Suited For | Limitations |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Slump Cone Test | IS 1199 Part 1 / ASTM C143 / BS EN 12350-2 | 25 – 225 mm | Abrams slump cone, steel plate, tamping rod, rule | 5 – 10 min | Normal-weight concrete; field quality control for most structural concrete | Not suitable for <25mm (use Vebe) or SCC (>220mm, use flow test); harsh mixes give false zero slump |
| Compacting Factor Test | IS 1199 Part 2 / BS 1881 Part 103 | Very Low – Medium (CF 0.70–0.95) | Compacting factor apparatus (two hoppers + cylinder), weighing balance | 10 – 15 min | Low workability mixes (0–50mm slump); precast, pavement concrete; more sensitive than slump in low range | Equipment bulky; not widely used in field; IS 1199 Part 2 now revised to align with EN 12350 |
| Vebe Consistometer Test | IS 1199 Part 6 / BS EN 12350-3 | Very Stiff — 0–25 mm slump (Vebe 3–35 sec) | Vebe consistometer (vibrating table, cylindrical container, slump cone, transparent disc) | 5 – 15 min | Very stiff / zero slump concrete; RCC pavements; precast; dry mixes | Needs laboratory or controlled site; not suitable for workable mixes (>25mm slump); equipment requires calibration |
| Flow Table Test | IS 1199 Part 4 / BS EN 12350-5 | Medium – Very High (50–200mm slump equiv.) | Flow table (700×700mm), mini-slump cone, callipers | 5 – 10 min | Flowable concrete, pumped concrete, high-strength concrete; mortar and grout flowability | Less common in Indian practice; floor space needed; 15 drops standardized — operator technique critical |
| Slump Flow Test (SCC) | ASTM C1611 / BS EN 12350-8 | SCC only: 550 – 850 mm flow | Base plate (900×900mm), Abrams cone, T500 stopwatch, steel rule, callipers | 5 – 10 min | SCC — measures flowability and flow rate (T500); VS Index for segregation assessment | Only for SCC; not applicable to vibrated concrete; needs level surface and large base plate |
| J-Ring Test (SCC) | ASTM C1621 / BS EN 12350-12 | SCC: 500 – 750 mm flow | J-Ring (steel bar ring, 300mm dia.), base plate, slump cone | 5 – 10 min | SCC passing ability through reinforcement — measures blocking resistance | SCC only; used alongside slump flow test, not standalone; gap between bars must match design spacing |
| V-Funnel Test (SCC) | BS EN 12350-9 / EFNARC | SCC: T = 8 – 25 sec (VF1/VF2) | V-funnel (standard geometry), stopwatch, container | 5 – 10 min | SCC viscosity / flowability index; complements slump flow; detects blockage tendency | SCC only; operator-sensitive (gate opening technique); not for coarse aggregate >20mm |
| L-Box Test (SCC) | BS EN 12350-10 / EFNARC | SCC: H2/H1 ≥ 0.80 | L-Box apparatus, steel bars (10–16mm dia.), ruler | 10 – 15 min | SCC passing ability and blocking resistance in congested reinforcement situations | Large apparatus; SCC only; H2/H1 ratio must be ≥ 0.80 for acceptable SCC |
| U-Box Test (SCC) | JSCE-F 563 / EFNARC | SCC: Filling height ≥ 300mm | U-Box apparatus with gate and reinforcement grid | 10 – 15 min | SCC filling ability — used for sections with complex geometry | Less common in European practice; more used in Japan; specialist equipment needed |
| Penetration Resistance / Proctor Test | ASTM C403 / IS 8142 | 0 – 25 mm (zero slump range) | Proctor penetration apparatus, mortar sieve, cylindrical container | 15 – 30 min | Setting time determination; also used for stiff concrete consistency assessment | Primarily a setting time test; workability application limited |
| Mini-Slump Cone (UHPC / Mortar) 2026 | EN 1015-3 / Research standard | UHPC flow: 180 – 280 mm | Mini-cone (100mm base, 70mm top, 60mm height), glass plate, ruler | 3 – 5 min | UHPC, cementitious grouts, repair mortars — no coarse aggregate | Not standardized for structural concrete; aggregate size limit 2–4mm; research/development use primarily |
| Ball Penetration Test (Kelly Ball) | ASTM C360 (Withdrawn) | 75 – 225 mm slump equivalent | Kelly ball apparatus (152mm diameter, 13.6 kg) | 3 – 5 min | Field check on placed concrete in forms or on slabs — non-destructive of in-place concrete | ASTM C360 withdrawn 1999; still used in some regions; conversion: Slump ≈ 2 × ball penetration depth |
Workability is influenced by numerous interacting factors. Understanding their quantified effects is essential for mix design, site troubleshooting, and quality control. Reference: PCA Design and Control of Concrete Mixtures and ACI 308R.
← Scroll left/right to view full table
| Factor | Effect on Workability / Slump | Quantified Impact | Practical Implication |
|---|---|---|---|
| Water Content (w/c ratio) | Most direct influence — increases directly with water content | +10 liters/m³ water ≈ +25–35 mm slump increase | Never add water on site to increase slump — increases w/c, reduces strength 5–6 MPa per 10L additional water |
| Cement Content | Higher cement = more paste = improved workability at same w/c | +50 kg/m³ cement ≈ +10–20 mm slump at constant w/c | Rich mixes are inherently more workable; lean mixes need admixtures to achieve target slump |
| Water-Cement Ratio | Governs both workability and strength — higher w/c improves workability but reduces strength | w/c 0.40→0.50 ≈ +40–60 mm slump; strength reduces ~5–8 MPa | Maintain target w/c; use admixtures to achieve workability without changing w/c |
| Aggregate Maximum Size (MSA) | Larger MSA = less surface area = less water needed = better workability at same water content | Increasing MSA from 10mm to 20mm saves ~10–15 liters/m³ water at same slump | Use maximum allowable MSA per IS 456 Cl. 5.3.1 for economy and workability |
| Aggregate Shape — Angular vs Rounded | Rounded (river gravel) more workable than angular (crushed) at same water content | Angular aggregate reduces slump by 15–30mm vs. rounded at same mix proportions | Increase water or SP dosage by 5–10% when switching from rounded to crushed angular aggregate |
| Fine Aggregate (FA) Proportion | Increasing FA% improves cohesion but reduces slump (more surface area) | Each +5% FA content reduces slump by approximately 10–20 mm | Balance FA/CA ratio for workability AND segregation resistance — too little FA causes harsh, bleeding mix |
| Fine Aggregate Grading Zone | Finer FA (Zone III/IV) increases water demand and reduces workability | Zone IV FA may require +10–20 liters/m³ vs Zone II at same slump | Blend or upgrade FA zone; compensate with superplasticizer rather than added water |
| Superplasticizer / PCE Admixture | Major workability enhancer — disperses cement particles, reduces water demand | 1.0% PCE dosage ≈ +80–120 mm slump OR 20–35% water reduction at same slump | Primary tool for achieving high workability without increasing w/c; use to maintain slump in hot weather |
| Normal Water Reducer (Lignosulfonate) | Moderate workability improvement | 0.4% dosage ≈ +30–50 mm slump OR 5–12% water reduction | Economical for M20–M35 concrete; limited effectiveness for high slump targets |
| Concrete Temperature | Higher temperature reduces workability — accelerates hydration and water evaporation | +10°C rise ≈ −20 to −40 mm slump loss; slump loss doubles for every 10°C above 25°C | Add retarder in hot weather; chill mixing water/aggregates; test slump at pour point, not at drum |
| Ambient Temperature & Wind | High ambient temp + wind accelerates evaporation — reduces slump in transit | At 40°C, slump loss can be 20–50mm per 30 min of transit/waiting | Insulate drum; specify slump at point of discharge; avoid delay between mixing and placing |
| Supplementary Cementitious Materials (SCMs) | Fly ash improves workability (spherical particles); GGBS neutral to slight positive; silica fume reduces | 30% FA replacement: +20–40 mm slump. 10% silica fume: −20 to −40 mm slump | Account for SCM effect in mix design water content; silica fume mixes always need PCE superplasticizer |
| Air Entrainment | Each 1% air increases workability slightly | 4% air ≈ +10–20 mm slump equivalent; allows ~5 liters/m³ water reduction | Beneficial in freeze-thaw climates; air content must be maintained within ±1.5% of target |
| Mixing Time & Mixer Type | Adequate mixing improves uniformity and apparent workability | Under-mixing (under 90 sec) can reduce effective slump 15–30mm due to unmixed dry lumps | Minimum 2 minutes mixing after all materials loaded (IS 456 Cl. 9.2); drum speed affects uniformity |
| Time After Mixing (Slump Loss) | Slump decreases with time due to hydration, evaporation, and admixture consumption | Normal concrete: 20–40mm/hr slump loss; with PCE: 10–20mm/hr; at 35°C: 40–80mm/hr | Specify slump at point of placement; allow for transit time; add retarder for long hauls (>45 min) |
| Steel Fibres (SFRC) 2026 | Fibres reduce workability significantly — increase mix stiffness | 50 kg/m³ steel fibres ≈ −30 to −70 mm slump; longer fibres (60mm) worse than shorter (30mm) | Increase SP dosage 20–30% for SFRC; use slump flow test not cone test for SFRC SCC; target flow >600mm |
| Nano-Silica Addition 2026 | Significantly increases SP demand; reduces apparent slump at same SP dose | 2% nano-SiO₂ ≈ −30 to −60 mm slump at same SP dosage; requires +20–30% more SP | Always recalibrate SP dosage in trial mixes when adding nano-silica; add in colloidal suspension form |
The fundamental conflict in concrete mix design is that increasing water content improves workability but reduces strength (Abrams Law). The 2026 solution — use superplasticizers to achieve high workability at low w/c ratios. Reference: ACI 318-19 Section 26.4 and IS 10262:2019.
← Scroll left/right to view full table
| Concrete Grade (IS) | Max w/c Ratio (IS 456) | Design Slump (mm) | Without Admixture — Approx. Mix Water (liters/m³) | With PCE SP — Mix Water (liters/m³) | Water Saved (liters/m³) | EN Slump Class Achievable |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| M20 | 0.55 | 75–100 | 186–196 | 165–178 | 10–20 | S2–S3 |
| M25 | 0.50 | 75–100 | 186–196 | 160–175 | 15–25 | S2–S3 |
| M30 | 0.45 | 100–125 | 196–208 | 158–172 | 25–40 | S3 |
| M35 | 0.45 | 100–150 | 196–210 | 155–168 | 30–50 | S3–S4 |
| M40 | 0.40 | 100–150 | 196–210 | 148–162 | 38–55 | S3–S4 |
| M50 | 0.36 | 120–160 | 210–225 | 145–158 | 50–70 | S3–S4 |
| M60 | 0.32 | 120–170 | 215–230 | 140–155 | 60–80 | S3–S5 |
| M80 UHSC 2026 | 0.26 | 150–200 | N/A (requires PCE) | 130–148 | N/A (PCE mandatory) | S4–S5 |
| M100+ UHPC 2026 | 0.20 | Flow 200–260mm (mini-cone) | N/A (requires PCE powder) | 115–130 | N/A | No standard class — flow test |
SCC requires a unique multi-test approach to characterise the three key fresh properties: flowability (slump flow), viscosity (T500 / V-funnel time), and passing ability (J-ring, L-box). All three must be simultaneously satisfied. Reference: EFNARC European Guidelines for Self-Compacting Concrete 2005 and ASTM C1611, C1621.
← Scroll left/right to view full table
| SCC Test | Standard | Class 1 (Low Fluidity) | Class 2 (Normal) | Class 3 (High Fluidity) | Rejection Criterion |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Slump Flow | EN 12350-8 / ASTM C1611 | SF1: 550–650 mm | SF2: 660–750 mm | SF3: 760–850 mm | <500mm or >900mm — reject; visible segregation (VSI ≥ 3) — reject |
| T500 Flow Time | EN 12350-8 / ASTM C1611 | VS2: T500 ≥ 3 sec | VS1: T500 < 3 sec | VS1: T500 < 2 sec | T500 > 8 sec = excessive viscosity; T500 < 1 sec = too fluid / segregation risk |
| V-Funnel Time | EN 12350-9 | VF2: 9–25 sec | VF1: 6–12 sec | VF1: <8 sec | >25 sec = too viscous / blocking; <6 sec = segregation risk |
| J-Ring Slump Flow | EN 12350-12 / ASTM C1621 | PJ1: Δflow ≤ 50mm | PJ2: Δflow ≤ 25mm | PJ2: Δflow ≤ 25mm | Δflow >50mm = blocking — mix fails passing ability; rebar spacing must match J-ring gap |
| L-Box Ratio (H2/H1) | EN 12350-10 | PA1: ≥ 0.80 (2 bars) | PA2: ≥ 0.80 (3 bars) | PA2: ≥ 0.80 (3 bars) | <0.80 = blocking — fail; concrete does not fill around reinforcement |
| Segregation Resistance (Sieve Stability) | EN 12350-11 | SR1: ≤ 20% | SR1: ≤ 20% | SR2: ≤ 15% | >20% = excessive segregation — fail; increase VMA or reduce SP |
| Visual Stability Index (VSI) | ASTM C1611 | VSI 0–1: Stable | VSI 1: Stable | VSI 0: Highly Stable | VSI 2 = unstable; VSI 3 = unacceptable — highly segregating; reject |